How does madara know tobi

For example, Tobi explained to Sasuke how the Uchiha revolution began, including the motivations of both the Uchiha and Konoha. After talking this over with a friend of mine, we found a interview of the author of Naruto.

Is Toby really Izuna? There is no evidence indicating this interview is real. Regardless, it poses a good question: Is Tobi really Izuna? The other Uchiha would not be as easy of targets. Tobi later fell asleep on top the Three-Tails after making another cheeky comment, much to the anger of Deidara, who "woke him up" by detonating a clay bomb next to him.

Once the sealing was complete, Deidara, angry that he had not got to kill Orochimaru, brought Tobi with him to kill Sasuke instead. They found and confronted Sasuke, and Tobi was given the job of providing assistance for Deidara during the battle. After some initial taunting from the duo, Sasuke surprised them both with his extreme speed and ran his sword straight through Tobi, apparently disemboweling him. Tobi then suddenly stood up again, complaining about the speed of the attack.

The battle ultimately didn't go in Deidara's favor, so he used C0 in an effort to kill Sasuke at the loss of his own life. Zetsu reported to the remaining members of Akatsuki that Tobi had been killed too, prompting Pain to remark that he was easily replaceable. It was soon revealed, however, that Tobi had survived, as he met with Pain and Konan in Amegakure. Tobi, revealing himself as Madara, remarks that Sasuke is developing nicely.

The Konoha ninja had no success in striking him with their attacks, so Shino Aburame volunteered to fight Madara one-on-one. With his bugs, Shino was able to box-in and catch Madara, but Madara was able to escape from this as well. Zetsu then arrived to inform him that Sasuke had killed Itachi. Madara pointed out that he had known that this would be the outcome, and went to see Sasuke.

Before leaving, his Sharingan was spotted by Kakashi. Madara tended to Sasuke's wounds and, when he woke up, offered to tell him about Itachi. After stopping the black flames, Madara then appeared again with his mask back on, and began to muse about how Itachi never ceased to amaze him.

After Sasuke complained that he was making no sense, Madara revealed that it was to protect him, and, when Sasuke still didn't believe him, Madara said how it all must sound crazy but assured him that he was telling the truth, and introduced himself as the man who had helped Itachi on that fateful night.

He told Sasuke about the Uchiha clan's history, Itachi's secret life, and the lengths he had gone to keep Sasuke and Konoha out of harm's way. He also however lied about his involvement with the Nine-Tails attack 16 years ago, saying instead that it was just a coincidental act of nature. Sasuke, regretting that he had killed Itachi now that he knew the truth, resolved to destroy Konoha for forcing Itachi into the life he had lived.

Madara convinced Sasuke and the other members of Taka to start working with Akatsuki, the two groups having Konoha's destruction as a mutual goal. Before they could do that, however, he stated that Akatsuki needed the two remaining tailed beasts. After Taka left, Madara spoke with Zetsu, discussing Akatsuki's actions up to that point.

He went on to say that, although they had lost five talented ninja in Akatsuki, all of their efforts had brought him closer to "making Sasuke his". During the extraction process, it was revealed to be a fake. Zetsu informed Madara of Nagato 's failure to capture Naruto, his betrayal of Akatsuki, and his sacrificing himself to revive the Konoha villagers he killed.

Then went to confront Sasuke, who was taking Taka to Konoha. Madara instructs Zetsu to lead Taka to the Land of Iron , but when they arrive he has Zetsu reveal their presence to the Kage. He tried to figure out how Naruto was able to cause Nagato to have a change of heart, but was caught by Kakashi Hatake and Yamato. Rather than fight, Madara told them about the Sage of the Six Paths , the truth of the Uchiha clan, and Sasuke's descent into darkness.

They doubt the validity of what he told them, but he persevered, saying that Naruto and Sasuke are destined to fight some day before disappearing. As Sasuke was about to be killed by the Kage, Madara rescued him.

He sends Sasuke away while having Karin go with him to heal his injuries. Madara voiced his disappointment that Sasuke was not more of a match for the Kage, having hoped to take them hostage to facilitate with his plans.

To that end, he asked the four Kage to give him Killer Bee and Naruto. Although forced to remove his arm during the battle because of Torune's Poisonous Nano Bugs Technique , Madara was easily able to dispose of the two. Madara observed the battle and was glad when Sasuke is finally able to fully develop Susanoo.

Sasuke then stated they would head to Konoha. Madara however, advised Sasuke not to be reckless, and that despite Karin healing his more serious wounds, he was still very battered and needed time to recover.

Sasuke merely stated he has never considered himself an ally of Madara. Later on, after gaining a new arm, and noting that he must collect the Rinnegan to prepare for war, Zetsu's white half appeared, stating that Sasuke was in trouble. Madara then teleported in front of Team 7 and told Sasuke to come with him and for Zetsu to check on Kisame and reunite with his other half and decides to leave Naruto's capturing to Sasuke.

Kakashi even started to piece it together in the anime by figuring out how similar their Sharingan abilities were. It's actually a surprise that it took the cast that long, considering just how obvious it was.

Granted, they never dealt with Tobi extensively until the war. There was never any chance that the man behind the mask was going to be someone whose name was never mentioned. It would have been anti-climatic and stripped away the momentum created after he claimed the position as the Akatsuki's leader.

That only left three options--Shisui, Madara, and Obito. Of the three, only Obito made sense as Madara was far too old and Shisui had already lost both of his eyes before he died. He was even the right age to pull off everything within the timeline. While the birth of Naruto was the most opportune time to strike to gain control of the Nine-Tails, it had to feel a little extra special for Obito to get back at his former mentor, Minato.

He hadn't been making any moves on any of the other tailed beasts at the time, so his decision to strike then had to have a deeper meaning, despite what he said. He would've been able to take everything away from Minato, just as everything had been taken from him when his master failed to save him or Rin. At first, what he did with Yagura was merely to give him control of a country, making him the defacto Mizukage.

That had to have changed slightly once he found out the truth about Rin, finding out that Kirigakure planned to make her into a timed bomb that would destroy Konoha via the Three-Tails. From this, it might be said that Obito was disguised as Madara when he revealed himself to Kisame. However, remember that during this time, Obito was already calling himself 'Madara'.

With long hair like those, with those eyes and the fact that few people has ever seen Madara's face, he could easily pass as one even with the scars on his face.

In Chapter , after Itachi's death and when Obito finally removed the mask to reveal himself to Kisame, Kisame was surprised. Because the 'Madara' that Kisame knew was not wearing any mask nor did he call himself 'Tobi'. When Tobi 'joined' the Akatsuki, he did not announce himself as 'Madara' but as Tobi, who Kisame was fond of. After Tobi presumably died, Kisame remarked that he was sorry to hear his death, especially since he Tobi lightens up the mood of the organization.

To conclude, we can say that the first time they met, Obito did reveal himself to Kisame scars in the face and all but under the name 'Madara'. The second time they met, it was as 'Tobi' and with a mask so Kisame did not know who was the man underneath the mask. When Tobi revealed himself, Kisame was surprised because he did not expect that it was 'Madara'. It could not have been that he was surprised of the scars because he immediately recognized him and he made no comment on them either so we can assume he's already seen his scarred face before.

I dont believe this is a plothole, because the first time Kisame met the "Madara", it was actually Obito disguised as Madara Uchiha , Although we never got to see the actual person that Kisame was talking to, based of the way the persons hair from the Shadow was, it looked exactly like Madara Uchihas hair, and we all know that Obito's hair looks very different and isn't spiky long.

I would guess that Obito probably used substitution Jutsu in order to resemble the real Madara. However, the second time, he saw Obitos real face and that probably caught him by surprise since he was not expecting those scars.

It might have something to do with the masks. Obito used two types of masks in the series, repeatedly switching between the two.

When he first meets nagato, konan and yahiko, he wears his "Tobi" mask.